BiH - Dayton Agreement - anniversary - article
11/21/2026
08:57

BANJA LUKA, NOVEMBER 21 /SRNA/ - The Dayton Agreement was not a victory for one side and a defeat for the others, but rather a historic compromise reached by the Serbs, Croats and Bosniaks after enormous sacrifices and deep divisions, constitutional law professor Siniša Karan stressed.
"No one got everything they wanted, but everyone accepted the limits of their political objectives for the sake of the most important common interest – peace," Professor Karan wrote in an article for the Media System of Republika Srpska – SRNA, marking the 31st anniversary of the initialing of the Dayton Peace Agreement on November 21, 1995, at Wright-Patterson Air Force Base in Dayton, USA.
SRNA is publishing Professor Karan's article in full:
For 31 years, political Sarajevo has sought to change the very essence of the Dayton Agreement and its annexes, replacing the constitutional compromise with domination and trying to transform BiH's complex confederal-federal structure into a unitary state.
BiH has been brought to a point where respect for the Constitution and the Dayton Agreement has become a problem, while circumventing and undermining them is portrayed as progress.
Dayton was not a victory for one side and a defeat for the others; it was a historic compromise reached by the Serbs, Croats and Bosniaks after enormous sacrifices and deep divisions. No one got everything they wanted, but everyone accepted limits on their political objectives for the sake of the most important common interest—peace.
Republika Srpska brought its statehood, institutions, and constitutional and legal subjectivity to this compromise. It accepted the Dayton constitutional framework of BiH, but did not accept its subsequent unilateral amendment, the gradual stripping away of its powers, or the imposition of Sarajevo's political will as an obligation.
THE PASSAGE OF TIME IS NOT A LEGAL BASIS
Republika Srpska and Dayton-based BiH rest on the four-plus-three formula, as opposed to the anti-Dayton five-plus-two formula. This means four pillars: the will of the people, international verification, economic self-sufficiency and the strength of institutions; and three principles of a functioning federal state: parity, consensus and the division of powers.
However, the Dayton architecture, based on the constitutional role of the constituent peoples and entities as holders of sovereignty, has been subjected for 31 years to interventions by High Representatives, controversial constitutional court interpretations and international political conditionality.
Under such circumstances, the argument that the prolonged implementation of a particular imposed, undemocratic and anti-Dayton solution in itself proves its constitutionality is particularly dangerous.
The passage of time cannot overcome or remedy unconstitutionality, political coercion cannot be transformed into consent, and institutional practice cannot replace a constitutional norm.
PROTECT DAYTON THROUGH REASSESSMENT
The Constitution of BiH, which is also Annex 4 to the Dayton Agreement, provides for the possibility of transferring additional responsibilities, subject to the consent of the entities. However, each specific transfer must have a clear constitutional basis and meet the prescribed requirements.
Even subsequent parliamentary adoption does not constitute grounds for prohibiting debate on the constitutional basis, the nature of the consent given, and the circumstances under which certain arrangements came about. This is because everything that has been adopted must also be examined in light of the circumstances under which it was adopted.
Everything that came about outside the original Dayton constitutional framework must be reassessed, and everything that was imposed must be subjected to a review of its constitutional basis. Ultimately, anti-Dayton and unconstitutional decisions must be removed from the legal order of BiH.
Reassessing arrangements introduced after 1995 is not an attempt to dismantle Dayton. On the contrary, it is a demand to put an end to its continued erosion. The greatest threat to BiH is not the demand to review disputed decisions, but the denial of its Dayton-based nature, whereby imposition becomes a permanent substitute for agreement.
If the Dayton Peace Agreement represented a historic compromise that established peace in 1995, then that compromise must be consistently respected in 2026 as well, without the subsequent imposition of solutions, political experiments, or unilateral rewriting of what was agreed, because BiH can survive only as long as no one has the power to outvote the others.
Republika Srpska is the only entity in BiH that consistently defends the original Dayton Agreement, and this is precisely where the greatest paradox lies: the side insisting on respect for the signed Agreement is portrayed as the problem, while those who have spent years undermining and rewriting it are presented as its defenders.