BiH - truncated Constitutional Court - Nikolić
11/21/2026
09:30

BELGRADE, NOVEMBER 21 /SRNA/ - The latest decision by the truncated Constitutional Court of BiH against Republika Srpska is merely a continuation of the erosion of the Dayton Peace Agreement, which cannot be interpreted in a way that turns its safeguards into an empty formality, Assistant Professor at the University of Belgrade Faculty of Law Aleksa Nikolić told SRNA.
Nikolić said that the decision by the truncated Constitutional Court of BiH to invalidate the statement by Serb member of the BiH Presidency Željka Cvijanović that the vital interests of Republika Srpska were under threat, as well as the National Assembly's decision endorsing that statement, raises a much broader issue than the appointment of members of the Commission to Preserve National Monuments.
"This concerns the nature of the Dayton constitutional order, the position of the entities and the actual scope of the mechanisms intended to prevent domination by the majority," Nikolić said.
According to him, this is why the decision by the truncated Constitutional Court of BiH deserves more serious attention than day-to-day political debate.
He stressed that the fundamental question was not whether the appointment of members of the Commission to Preserve National Monuments was justified, but what the constitutional guarantee of protecting the vital interests of an entity actually means.
He explained that Article V of the Constitution of BiH provides for a special protection mechanism, under which a member of the Presidency who disagrees with a particular decision may declare it destructive to the vital interests of the entity from whose territory he or she was elected.
"If such a statement is endorsed by a two-thirds majority of the Republika Srpska National Assembly, the contested decision does not enter into force," Nikolić explained.
As he pointed out, this is neither a political ornament nor a mere procedural formality, but a constitutional safeguard established precisely because decision-making in joint institutions cannot be based exclusively on the principle of majority rule.
"The right to protect vital interests was not conceived as a privilege that can be exercised only when other participants in the political process agree with it," Nikolić specified.
He added that its purpose was to prevent the political will of one part of the country from being turned into a binding decision for everyone, without appropriate safeguards.
Nikolić stressed that it was particularly important to clarify the relationship between the competences of the joint institutions, the nature of the contested decision and the possibility of activating the vital national interest protection mechanism.
"The fact that the Commission to Preserve National Monuments is an institution whose importance is established under Annex Eight to the Dayton Agreement does not mean that issues concerning its composition and functioning fall outside the scope of Republika Srpska's constitutional interests. The way joint institutions function, make decisions and respect the constitutional position of the entities is at the very heart of the Dayton compromise," Nikolić said.
He pointed out that the constitutional order of Dayton-based BiH was not established as a result of agreement on a shared political identity, but rather as the result of a constitutional compromise between different political communities.
Its distinctive feature, he said, lies precisely in the fact that it established joint institutions without abolishing the political autonomy and constitutional position of the entities.
He said that the Dayton Agreement did not merely end the war, but also established a specific architecture of power-sharing, mutual checks and institutional safeguards, without which the functioning of BiH would be difficult to envisage.
Nikolić said that the decision by the truncated Constitutional Court could not be viewed in isolation from the question of the future of BiH’s Dayton-based constitutional order, since BiH could be stable only if the constitutional compromise was respected.
“Constitutional loyalty does not mean merely accepting the decisions of institutions, but also respecting the limits of their authority,” Nikolić said.
He pointed out that Dayton had not established a system in which Republika Srpska was supposed to be merely an executor of decisions made by the joint institutions, but rather one in which those institutions must respect its constitutional existence, status and competencies.
"That is the essence of the compromise from which present-day BiH emerged," Nikolić concluded.