BiH - judiciary - response
11/20/2026
18:27

SARAJEVO, NOVEMBER 20 /SRNA/ - Legal expert Ognjen Tadić warned that a ruling by the incomplete Constitutional Court of BiH was a new and serious blow to the constitutional order established by the Dayton Peace Accords. The court upheld a request by Denis Bećirović concerning a veto by Željka Cvijanović, the Serb member of the BiH Presidency, of the appointment of the Commission to Preserve National Monuments.
Tadić said the issue this time was not only that the ruling enabled the unlawful selection of the commission's members. It also directly encroached on the constitutional right of a BiH Presidency member to trigger the mechanism for protecting an entity's vital interest, which opened the way for the will of the court to override an explicit constitutional provision.
"The Constitutional Court is neither the author nor the owner of the BiH Constitution," Tadić told SRNA.
He reminded that the Constitution clearly set out the procedure for protecting an entity's vital interest. A member of the BiH Presidency launches it when they consider a decision destructive to the vital interest of the entity from which they were elected, and the relevant entity body then decides on the matter by a two-thirds majority.
Tadić said the mechanism for protecting an entity's vital interest was neither a political privilege nor an arbitrary act by Željka Cvijanović, but a constitutional right that came with the office she held.
"On what basis, then, does the incomplete Constitutional Court give itself room to strip this procedure of meaning by imposing additional restrictions, when the BiH Constitution already provides that a two-thirds majority of the Republika Srpska National Assembly decides whether the mechanism was justifiably invoked?" Tadić asked.
He added that a particularly problematic question was what gave the Constitutional Court jurisdiction to act on a request by one BiH Presidency member, in this case Denis Bećirović, challenging the actions of another member of the same institution.
"It is not enough for someone to turn to the Constitutional Court and ask for its opinion. Nor is it enough for the court to declare itself competent. A specific constitutional provision must be shown that gives it the right to rule on precisely this kind of request. When there is no such basis, this is not interpretation of the Constitution but an unconstitutional expansion of its own powers," Tadić warned.
He said that an institution charged with protecting the Constitution that set the limits of its own jurisdiction without a clear constitutional basis ceased to be a guarantor of constitutionality and became an obstacle to respect for it.