BiH

KARAN: INCOMPLETE CONSTITUTIONAL COURT HAS TORN DOWN DAYTON BiH - TRYING TO ERASE SRPSKA'S CONSTITUTIONAL POSITION

BiH - incomplete Constitutional Court - response

SOURCE: Srna

11/20/2026

18:26

KARAN: INCOMPLETE CONSTITUTIONAL COURT HAS TORN DOWN DAYTON BiH - TRYING TO ERASE SRPSKA'S CONSTITUTIONAL POSITION
Photo: SRNA

BANJA LUKA, NOVEMBER 20 /SRNA/ - Constitutional law professor Siniša Karan said that with its ruling on Friday, the incomplete Constitutional Court of BiH had dealt one of the heaviest blows of the past 31 years to Republika Srpska's constitutional position.


"This is no longer a matter of an individual court ruling. It is an open attack on the foundations of the Dayton constitutional order, on the equality of the constituent peoples and entities, and on the very mechanisms that prevent outvoting and domination," Karan told the Republika Srpska Media System - SRNA, commenting on Friday's rulings by the incomplete Constitutional Court of BiH.

Karan said that when a court ruling eliminated Republika Srpska's constitutional right to protect its vital interest, it changed not only the way decisions were made but the very constitutional nature of BiH.

"Over the past three decades we have witnessed numerous attempts to strip Republika Srpska of its powers, challenge its competences and impose solutions outside the Dayton constitutional compromise. However, the BiH Presidency member has a constitutional mechanism for protecting an entity's vital interest, and directly stripping that mechanism of meaning is a precedent with far-reaching constitutional, legal and political consequences. It strikes at one of the key constitutional barriers that prevent outvoting, unitarization and unilateral changes to the structure of the BiH state," Karan said.

He said the Dayton constitutional order had not established BiH as a unitary state. Instead, it had created a complex state structure based on two entities, the constituent status of its peoples and constitutional mechanisms to protect them.

He said parity, consensus, entity voting and protection of the vital interest were not minor procedural matters. They were fundamental guarantees of constitutional equality and a protection against majority domination.

He said the entities were not ordinary administrative units but constituent elements of the Dayton constitutional order, with their own powers and instruments to protect those powers.

"It should be reminded in particular that the BiH Constitution allows for the Serb member of the BiH Presidency to be outvoted, but that is precisely why it provides an additional protection mechanism. Under that mechanism, a decision declared destructive to an entity's vital interest is referred to the Republika Srpska National Assembly. That mechanism is a constitutional guarantee that outvoting will not turn into domination.

Neutralizing it destroys the balance on which the Dayton decision-making model rests. Outvoting then ceases to be a constitutionally limited possibility and becomes an instrument for imposing political will," Karan said.

He said this was the very essence of the Dayton compromise: no constituent people and no entity could be subordinated to the will of others. That, he said, was why there was entity voting in the BiH Parliamentary Assembly, protection of the vital national interest, and the right to protect an entity's vital interest in BiH Presidency decision-making.

"These are not obstacles to democracy but constitutional guarantees of democracy in a complex, multinational state. Without parity, consensus and effective protection mechanisms, the Dayton Constitution loses its essence and BiH drifts away from the principles on which it was founded," Karan added.

He said the most dangerous aspect of the ruling was that the BiH Constitutional Court had openly stepped out of its role as guardian of the Constitution and taken on the role of its framer.

"An institution that is duty-bound to protect the Constitution cannot change the very constitutional structure of the state under the pretext of interpreting it. This is not about protecting constitutionality. It is a de facto revision of the Constitution without changing a single letter of it, without a constitutional procedure and without the consent of the constituent peoples and entities," Karan said.

He said that by invoking the finality and binding nature of its decisions, the incomplete Constitutional Court was in effect creating a new constitutional reality, one that the legitimate representatives of the constituent peoples and entities had never agreed to.

"Add to that the fact that failure to enforce Constitutional Court decisions is a criminal offense, and it becomes clear what kind of power is being concentrated in the hands of an institution whose actions are taking it ever further from the Dayton constitutional framework. This is no longer the rule of the Constitution. It is an attempt to establish rule over the Constitution, a juristocracy in which the judiciary takes over the powers of the framers of the Constitution," the constitutional law professor said.

He said such actions were part of a wider push for the view that the Dayton Constitution was merely a temporary solution to be overcome, even without a formal constitutional agreement.

"Judicial interpretations are being used to achieve what there is no constitutional consensus for: the gradual removal of federal elements and the transformation of BiH into a unitary state. The Constitutional Court, however, has no mandate to decide what kind of country BiH should be. Its constitutional duty is to protect the existing constitutional order, not to rearrange it," Karan said.

For that reason, he said, the ruling could not be viewed in isolation. He called it an extremely dangerous step in a process of weakening Republika Srpska's constitutional mechanisms and of attempting to transform Dayton BiH informally.

He added that in defending its powers and its right to constitutional protection, Republika Srpska was also defending the very principle of equality on which the Dayton order rested.

"That principle must apply to all constituent peoples and to both entities, because equality and mutual respect are the basis of BiH's stability. If Republika Srpska's constitutional position can be changed without its consent, if entity protection mechanisms can be neutralized through judicial interpretation and if federal principles can be pushed aside without a formal constitutional revision, then we are no longer talking about applying the Dayton Constitution. We are talking about creating a new constitutional order without constitutional consent, a new state structure without agreement and new rules that bypass the prescribed constitutional procedure," Karan said.

He said this made the ruling one of the most serious challenges to the very logic of the Dayton constitutional order since it was established.

"The BiH Constitutional Court has no mandate to abolish Dayton, to change BiH's constitutional nature or to build a unitary state through court rulings. The moment the judges of the wretched incomplete Constitutional Court of BiH claimed the right to change the constitutional order they are duty-bound to protect, they ceased to be guardians of the Constitution and became its destroyers. And by tearing down the Dayton Constitution, they are tearing down not only Republika Srpska's constitutional position but also the foundations of the very BiH they swear by," Karan said.